I spent the week reading "Heartburn," which is such a stunner because of its honesty. Nora Ephron looks closely at the lowest point in her life; also, she refuses to make herself a victim. She pokes fun at herself and even seems to show compassion for Carl Bernstein (while also making clear that Carl Bernstein could benefit from professional help).
There is an artist with a "Nora Ephron" heart in "The Simpsons"; the artist is Barney Gumble. Invited to submit a short film to a contest, Barney leans in to self-deprecation. He admits that he is wedded to alcohol; it's a problem of his own making; he is in over his head.
Barney's iconic film--"Pukahontas"--features its protagonist in "toothless" mode; Barney is lying in a gutter. Bluntly, Barney makes a suggestion to his audience. "Don't cry for me. I am already dead." We also see Barney alone on a couch; the beer spills onto his chin and onto the furniture.
The amazing middle interlude shows Barney in a "healing circle." He says, "I'm forty, I'm single, and I drink. My name is Barney Gumble." Suddenly, we're looking at Lisa Simpson, who says, "Mr. Gumble, this is a meeting of the Girl Scouts."
Barney doesn't miss a beat. "You're Girl Scouts? Or you're lost souls--unable to admit that you have a problem...."
Barney's movie is clearly the best among many entries in Springfield; alone among the contestants, Barney understands the assignment. He captures the truth--and no one else (not Mr. Burns, not Ned Flanders, not Moe) can accomplish this. At the same time, Barney's film is absurd--not just because of the Girl Scouts, but also because of a quote from Shakespeare. (Reflecting on Shakespeare's words, Barney says, "Will pretty much covers it!")
This clip isn't even in a well-regarded episode, but "Pukahontas" is immortal. I can't think of another segment in which Barney's particular star shines so brightly.
Comments
Post a Comment