Beyonce is not my favorite performer; I quickly grow bored with songs of empowerment. I prefer singers who are more openly messy. Bonnie Raitt, Amy Winehouse, Adele. That said, I acknowledge that Beyonce does what she does very well. I particularly like "Irreplaceable," which casts Bey as a kind of all-powerful God: So go ahead and get gone-- Call up that chick and see if she's home. Oops! I bet you thought that I didn't know. What did you think I was puttin' you out for? Because you was untrue-- Rollin' her round in that car I bought you. Baby, drop them keys. Hurry up before your taxi leaves. It's this song that "Six" seems to borrow from (via "No Way")--especially in the bridge section. Because the writers are witty, "Six" inverts the Beyonce theme: Catherine of Aragon is wielding power *not* to evict a man but to preserve her own queendom. Then the stutter of the chorus--"n-n-n-n-no way"--seems to recall "C...
I think this will be my last post about "Hadestown." My admiration is really centered on Eurydice's "I Want" solo: I was alone so long-- I didn't even know that I was lonely. Out in the cold so long-- I didn't even know that I was cold. Turned my collar to the wind-- This is how it's always been. All I've ever known is how to hold my own-- But now I want to hold you, too. Is it possible to invent new twists in a love song? Here, the writers push us "on to" an exciting bridge by dropping the last syllable in the refrain: "Now I want to hold you, too." Now I want to hold you--NOW. I want to hold you--hold you CLOSE. I don't wanna ever let you go. Now I wanna hold you--hold you TIGHT. I don't wanna go back to the lonely life. The other part I admire is the odd discordant passage at the end. Eurydice demands that Orpheus make several promises. Orpheus immediately complies; he is naive, and he believes that the promises a...